
Tim Cohen - Magic Trick (2011) [Captured Tracks] // Grade: B+
The worst thing about Tim Cohen’s Magic Trick is the artwork. Everything else about the Bay Area singer’s latest solo effort—the macabre western twang, the girl-group support, the deadpan croon and the wistful strides— is simply grand. The third release from the leader of the psych-leaning 60s rockers The Fresh and Onlys, Magic Trick, continues the bearded 33-year-old’s prolific past by following both 2009’s The Two Sides and last year’s Laugh Tracks with an appropriate, next-step march through tales of love, heartbreak and solitude.
Over 12 songs, Cohen’s march—backed by members of the Kelley Stoltz band, Aislers Set and other musical friends— sees the singer stopping off to drop a line from many distinctive vantage points of rock/pop history. There are appropriate nods to a variety of different singers, many of whom are the ones with the famous voices you’ve heard before: Chris Bell, Nico, Roy Orbison, Scott Walker, Jens Lekman and that other Cohen called Leonard, remind throughout. Whereas The Fresh and Onlys spend their time pouring through the former genre’s native serration and force, solo, Cohen wanders more through himself, tumbling in the motions of loyalty and betrayal that comes from moving in and out of love. On after-hours strummer “The Flower” over lulling female voices, he yearns: “Give me one more chance to show the world that all of my intentions are pure.” Those “intentions” are then seemingly discarded on the rockier standout “The Spirit’s Inside” when he admits he’s just here “to capture young fancies and undress them all.”
Longer than the last Fresh and Onlys’ LP and released simultaneously with the eight-song solo EP Bad Blood, Cohen makes certain he’s keeping us entertained on Magic Trick, not missing a beat in delivering on the hope of any solo record in framing its singer right at the center. Through decorative arrangements, vintage theatrics and playful piano, the release’s real joy comes from the time you spend swimming laps in Cohen’s deadpan croon. On the ever-growing “Season of Fires,” one of the best of the lot already, it’s his surprising amount of pedigree singing that holds the bouncy, Ariel Pink-like funk jammer together. Consider it the solo answer to his other project’s hit “Invisible Forces.”
Cohen spent last year a transient (his label’s word), touring and playing as a Fresh and Only. Outside of the musical proficiency that comes from within these solo tracks, his home-recorded latest goes after an encapsulation of “almost every moment of solitude, longing, and wonderment” from his days on tour. Though he dubs this song collection a Magic Trick, I can’t much imagine Cohen snapping his fingers to disappear somewhere new; it’s just too much rooted in his own sincerity for that to happen. So, it’s no wonder he confessed to “Impose” that “It’s [simply] how my mind and body work. It’s all I know how to do – record songs.” It’s lucky for us he shines at that one thing. Now, if we can only do something about that artwork…
