The High Five: Academy Edition – Worst Films To Win Best Picture
Thursday, February 23rd, 2012So it’s that time of year again: the Academy Awards are this weekend. I’m gonna do something really original and edgy and cool and talk about how LAME the Oscars are and how everyone who votes is a big old white dummy-dude (seriously though, you guys all saw that article right?) and how the movies they pick are all dumb and stoopid and how the ceremony is too long and boring and enjoys the smell of its own farts. You know you’re in a bad place when Oscar hating is so common that it’s now the norm and being into them is the new counterculture.
Now watch me have this piece of fucking cake and eat it too, internet. Because y’know why the Oscars get so much hate? Because they legitimately suck and make bad decisions. This is by no means a new thing. Crappy flicks have been winning that golden dildo for decades now, and we eat it up like the wonderful, iPad-having pigs that we are. Some years you could even be convinced that you were ready the list of Razzie winners. There are some in particular that stand out though, so today I’m going to talk about the 5 worst movies ever to win Best Picture. Bear in mind I’m not taking into account egregious snubs. For instance: Ordinary People is a perfectly fine movie, but it’s probably the worst best picture winner ever solely because it somehow beat Raging Bull. This is not that list. This is a list of legitimate badness. Here are the High Five.
—–
Honorable Mentions: Around The World In 80 Days (1956) & Driving Miss Daisy (1989)
Alright so let’s start slow. Rule of thumb: if you’re movie can later be easily remade as a later years Jackie Chan vehicle and no one bats an eye, instead saying “oh yeah. That makes sense I guess,” then you were probably never meant to be best picture material in the first place. This film does have a classic Saul Bass credits sequence, I’ll give it that, but the ensuing 3 hours are more or less interminable.
Driving Miss Daisy, on the other hand, is just plain tone deaf. Like, very very difficult to watch at this point. Not only is it schmaltzy and saccharine to the max (a common theme among Oscar winners) but it’s not-so-covertly pretty fucking racist. The fact that it’s become such a pun is a testament to the fact that we’ve all collectively decided that we made a grave, grave error with this one.
—–
5. The Hurt Locker (2010) – Dir. Kathryn Bigelow
A more or less brain dead action film that shamelessly latched onto a horrific war and rode that gravy train straight to Oscar glory. This movie is goofy as shit, and it pisses me off how much love it got, especially in the screenplay department. I will admit that, at least the first few bomb disarming sequences ratchet up a respectable level of tension, but as the film moves along it becomes very apparent just how dumbly this movie is approaching a gravely serious topic. This movie is secretly about as serious as Kathryn Bigelow’s far superior Point Break.
From bizarre stunt castings to a cavalcade of clunkers like “Be the best that I can be? What if the best I can be is a body on the side of an Iraqi street?” (yeesh…) I found myself face-palming numerous times throughout this self-serious mess. It also happens to have one of the most ill-conceived and tonally confusing endings I’ve seen in a long time. The fact that Iraq war veterans consistently decry this movie publicly puts some embarrassing flies on top of the feces cake.
—–
4. A Beautiful Mind (2001) – Dir. Ron Howard
What we talk about when we talk about Oscar bait. Russel Crowe indulges all his dimmest and most misguided actor moves in this cringe-worthy story of mental illness and genius. He jumps and tic’s and skitters around as mathematician John Nash, replacing any sort of character depth with surface level mannerisms that just scream “my brain is broken, durrr!”. Then there’s the whole part where you’re informed the first 3rd of the movie, y’know the interesting part, never really happened at all. That’s fine at the end of a movie. Maybe.
But you cannot do that in the middle. No! Because then you can’t… it just… I mean… it’s so stupid! The movie also has pretty much nothing to say about mental illness, and it conveniently glosses over the more unfortunate aspects of John Nash’s personality, not to mention the fact that it never really establishes him as a genius in the world of the film beyond the scenes in which he’s fucking hallucinating. Mad wack homie.
—–
3. Oliver! (1968) – Dir. Carol Reed
A British musical starring kids? Oh god, just end me now. What’s that? There’s two and a half hours left? And they’re in an orphanage. Son of a bitch. This one might come more from my personal disposition more than any of the others, but I just can’t stand this interminable sing-fest. We had to watch it in elementary school and it gave me boredom nightmares for years.
Then I rewatched it later thinking “hey, there’s no way it was that bad right? I mean, it says on the box that it was Best Picture? This is gonna be-” that’s where I black out. When I came to I was naked and the DVD player was just stuffed with organ meat. “Can I have some more please?” No. No you may not.
—–
2. American Beauty (1999) – Dir. Sam Mendes
This movie is the equivalent of those gigantic Swiss Army Knives that are like 18 inches long and come with every blade or tool that’s ever been used by a biped. Sam Mendes’ debut picture is so stuffed with tricks and flourish that it barely has enough room to fellate itself. Don’t worry though, it finds a way. Repeatedly. Perhaps the film’s greatest sin is consistently begging you to like protagonist Lester Burnham, an asshole solipsist played to infuriating perfection by Kevin Spacey.
I swear I’m not a guy who is put off by white people problem movies. Hey, I fucking loved Greenberg! But American Beauty forces even me to call bullshit on the self-importance of the whole enterprise. Chris Cooper’s character is also incredibly problematic, managing to somehow be criticized by the film for being homophobic while also making the film incredibly homophobic. It’s a double rainbow of shittiness!
—–
1. Crash (2005) – Dir. Paul Haggis
Well, we all knew this was going to be here right? It combines all the worst traits of the movies above and somehow makes it even worse than the sum of its parts. Then – here’s the crazy part- like, everything is connected. Man. Crash is the ultimate trolling movie, and Paul Haggis laughed his ass to the winners podium on the back of a film that stars not only Ryan Phillipe, but also Ludacris and Brendan Frasier. For being a movie supposedly about what it’s like to live in a city, you get the feeling Haggis had never been in one before, perhaps having spent his life up to that point on the set of a soap opera. Is is racist? Check. Bad music? You betcha. Emotionally manipulative? The bullets are blanks! Over plotted? Does the Pope fucking hate this movie? I know it’s cliche to say, but I seriously doubt (and hope) there will ever be a Best Picture winner worse than this.










































































